Who owns your renewals right now?
Is it a Founder, an Account Executive who closed the deal two years ago, or whoever happens to pick up the phone when a customer is unhappy?
And when did you last find out a customer was leaving before they told you?
If those questions made you wince, you are not alone.
Most SaaS companies hire their first customer success leader later than they should, and usually in a hurry.
Let’s Dive In!
The signs you are already late
There is rarely a single moment when it becomes obvious. It creeps up. A few things tend to show up together:
- Renewals arrive as surprises rather than as planned conversations
- Your Account Executives are spending more time keeping customers than finding new ones
- Nobody can say with confidence which accounts are at risk this quarter
- Product hears about customer problems from support tickets, not from a person who owns the relationship
- The board has started asking about net revenue retention and the answer lives in a spreadsheet one Founder maintains
One of these on its own is normal growing pains. Three or four at once usually means the customer base has outgrown the people looking after it.
It is not about headcount
A common rule of thumb is to wait until you have a certain number of customers or a certain level of revenue. It is a reasonable starting point, but it misses the real question.
What matters is how much of your future revenue depends on customers you already have. If you sell annual contracts with meaningful expansion potential, retention starts to shape the forecast early. If you sell lots of small monthly contracts, a scaled, tech-touch model might carry you further before you need a dedicated leader.
So rather than counting logos, ask: if we lost our five biggest customers next year, who would have seen it coming?
If the honest answer is nobody, it is time.
Decide what the role owns before you write the job ad
This is where most first CS hires go wrong. The brief gets written quickly after a bad quarter and asks for everything – strategy, onboarding, support, renewals, upsell, a team, a tech stack, all from one person.
Before you open the role, write down answers to three questions:
- Does CS own the renewal? Some companies leave it with sales, others hand it to CS. Pick one.
- Who owns expansion? CS, account management, or the original AE. Blurry ownership here causes more friction than almost anything else.
- What number will this person be judged on? Gross retention, net retention, or a customer health measure. One number, agreed upfront.
The answers change the profile you need. A leader who will carry a commercial number looks quite different from one whose job is to make onboarding and adoption work.
Builder or scaler?
The second decision is about stage. Your first CS leader is almost always a builder. They will write the first playbooks, set up health scoring, probably carry a handful of key accounts themselves and hire the first few CSMs.
That is a different person from a VP of Customer Success who has run managers, built a function across regions and presented retention to a board. Both are good people. Hiring the scaler when you need the builder is one of the more expensive mistakes we see. They arrive expecting a team and a system, find neither, and either try to build it slowly or leave.
If you are not sure which you need, think about the next twelve to eighteen months rather than the next three years. You can hire a VP above or alongside a strong builder later. It is much harder to turn a scaler into someone who enjoys working in the detail.
Head of, VP or CCO?
Titles matter less than scope, but they do affect who applies. Broadly:
- Head of Customer Success – usually the first leader, hands-on, building the function
- VP of Customer Success – running managers, owning retention at leadership level, working closely with the CRO
- Chief Customer Officer – CS, support, onboarding and sometimes account management under one person
Over-titling a hands-on role can attract the wrong candidates and set expectations you cannot meet. Under-titling a strategic one can put off the people you actually want. Match the title to the scope you have written down, not the other way round.
What to look for in the interview
Ask candidates to walk you through a renewal they nearly lost. What did they see first? What did they change afterwards? Strong CS leaders talk about patterns and systems, not just heroics with a single account.
Ask how they have worked with sales on handoffs. Where did it break down, and what did they do about it? The relationship between CS and sales will define how well this hire works.
And ask what they would want to know about your customers in their first thirty days. The best answers are curious and specific. They want to talk to customers, not just read the dashboard.
Getting the timing right
If you are reading this and thinking you probably needed someone six months ago, that is fine. Most companies do. The cost of waiting a little longer to get the brief right is much smaller than the cost of hiring the wrong shape of leader quickly.
So go back to the opening question. Who owns your renewals right now? If you would like help working out what your first customer success leader should own, and finding the right person for it, have a look at our Head of Customer Success recruitment page or book a call with the team.
Invest in a SaaS Sales Recruitment agency and accelerate your path to success.
Reach out to a member of the team here, or see more about how we can support your growth here.
